CMS proposes 2028 Medicare Advantage rule with food benefit standard and mandatory model

Proposed rule would require healthy food benefits based on Dietary Guidelines, create first mandatory Medicare Advantage model, and simplify Star Ratings.

By Ruth Kaplan, Health systems correspondent
. 3-minute read.
Illustration: CMS headquarters Woodlawn
Illustration: Clinical Observer

CMS filed a proposed rule on Nov. 20 for Medicare Advantage, Part D, and PACE contract year 2028, according to the proposed rule. The rule, CMS-4214-P2, was filed for public inspection Friday and will be published in the Federal Register on Nov. 25; comments must be received by 5 p.m. Eastern Time 60 days after the date of filing for public inspection. According to a fact sheet cited by Clinical Observer, the proposal would define healthy food for supplemental benefits using the Dietary Guidelines, establish the Innovation Center's first mandatory Medicare Advantage model, simplify Star Ratings, and relax some network adequacy requirements.

The food and beverage standard would require benefits to be whole and nutrient-dense, following the Dietary Guidelines for Americans, 2025–2030. Products that do not meet the standard, such as some high-calorie oral nutrition products, would still be covered if a provider recommends them for a patient's medical needs. The press release noted that chronically ill enrollees used the Special Supplemental Benefits for the Chronically Ill food and produce benefit about 40 million times in 2025. HHS Secretary Robert F. Kennedy Jr. said, "Medicare food benefits should pay for nutritious food that helps people improve their health and manage chronic disease."

The 10-year ADVaNCE MA model being proposed would start in 2029, with a pre-implementation phase beginning June 8, 2027, and would run in randomly selected states. CMS describes it as the Innovation Center's first mandatory MA model. The model would include a shadow test of a risk adjustment system inferred from Medicare claims, encounters, and enrollment records; a localized Diamond Ratings System that would substitute for Star Ratings in certain states; and new benefits for low-income subsidy enrollees that include healthy food, transportation, and caregiver support. The agency is considering, but has not proposed, excluding dialysis services for enrollees with end-stage renal disease.

CMS would narrow Star Ratings to 15 measures, emphasizing clinical outcomes and patient experience along with a small number of process measures where performance is poor. The agency proposes eliminating the reward factor and modifying the hold harmless methodology so it would protect only contracts rated 4.5 or more stars. The measure removals would apply to the 2028 measurement period and the 2030 Star Ratings.

To encourage market entry, CMS proposes shifting network adequacy checks from the time a plan applies to the first year it operates in a new or expanded service area. CMS would merge the outpatient behavioral health, clinical psychology, and clinical social work categories into one specialty and raise the telehealth credit above the current 10 percentage points. The rule would also create a process for enrollment capacity limits and a special enrollment period for people whose chosen plan reaches capacity.

For special needs plans, CMS would require chronic condition and certain institutional plans where at least 60 percent of enrollees are dually eligible to coordinate with Medicaid across care settings. The rule would revise the definition of fully integrated dual eligible special needs plans so that one legal entity does not have to hold both the Medicare and Medicaid contracts, and would broaden the highly integrated D-SNP definition so additional contractual arrangements qualify.

The proposal would remove CMS's set limits on agent and broker pay and renewals, as well as caps on referral fees and redundant training and reporting mandates. Instead, the agency would rely on market-based safeguards, flag unusual compensation patterns, and allow pay changes during the plan year with prior notice.

For Part B drugs that are selected for maximum fair price negotiation, Medicare Advantage contracts would have to require providers to sign up for the Medicare Transaction Facilitator Data Module. Plans would submit encounter data records within 30 days, collect 11-digit National Drug Codes, and cap out-of-network cost sharing at or below the negotiated maximum fair price.

Sources: Federal Register, Clinical Observer

Ruth KaplanHealth systems correspondent

Ruth Kaplan covers hospitals, health systems and the business of care for Clinical Observer. She writes from published reporting, filings and official statements.

Corrections. Report an error to corrections@clinicalobserver.com. Read our corrections policy.